2017 (Theory): Keegan and Hofman argue that the differences between Meillacoid and Chicoid pottery represent two distinct but overlapping “worlds” within the…

2017 (Theory): Keegan and Hofman argue that the differences between Meillacoid and Chicoid pottery represent two distinct but overlapping “worlds” within the Greater Antilles. While Meillacoid focuses on intricate, narrow-line incision and appliqué, Chicoid emphasizes broad-line modeling and high-polish finishes. These stylistic variations are more than just aesthetic choices; they reflect different social identities and historical trajectories among the island populations. By analyzing the paste, shape, and decoration of these ceramics, researchers can reconstruct the shifting alliances and trade networks of the pre-Columbian era. This “kaleidoscopic” approach allows for a more detailed understanding of how indigenous cultures maintained their uniqueness while participating in a shared regional system.